The Issues. I know I have put you through this before, but in an attempt to help me find clarity here they are again.
Alice:
- Alice is bright, clever, intelligent.
- In China, Alice was in 4th grade when she should be in 6th or 7th for her age (due to late start, not lack of ability).
- In China, Alice was a top student and loved school.
- Alice is social and misses the daily interaction with other kids, especially girlfriends.
- Alice is tolerating my presence 24/7, but is showing signs that she is feeling micromanaged. (guilty)
- Alice is still learning about parent/child relationship and "parent as teacher" isn't working very well at the moment.
- While Alice's English is improving daily, she is currently reading below a first grade level with little to no comprehension of what she read.
Public School:
- Our local public school would place Alice in 6th grade (a 2 year academic jump).
- The school would place her in classes at grade level and it would be up to each teacher to modify her assignments for her limited English proficiency.
- There was no plan presented for how the school would provide instruction to fill the gaps caused by skipping 2 grades. (Math & English being the primary problems.)
- The school would provide her 2 hours per week with an ESL (English as a Second Language) instructor. That teacher could either pull her out of class or work with her in one of her regular classes.
- Our local middle school is the largest in the county with 1500 students. (This causes me anxiety.)
Private School:
- There are a variety of private schools in our area.
- So far I have not found any that have the flexibility or willingness to address Alice's unique situation - at least not at a price we can afford.
- Cost for the really good private schools exceed the university tuition prices for our older 3's college educations. Even the smaller schools aren't cheap.
Homeschool:
- Academically, I think it is the best option because I can tailor the instruction to her language ability and progress at whatever pace she needs in each subject.
- I have not found any homeschool coops in our area that would give Alice the classroom experience and social outlet she desires. The handful of coops available for middle school level students have a strong academic focus and expect students to perform at or above grade level. Like the public school, they lack the flexibility to meet Alice where she is at the moment.
- While I continue to search for an active homeschool group for her to be involved with, I have been disappointed in what is available for her age.
- I am finding it difficult to provide the structure that Alice needs. I am struggling a bit with structure after having several years of "freedom" from the daily routine of parenting.
- I know that Alice and I need something to dilute our time together. I need a break from her as much as she needs a break from me now and then.
Pinch points:
- language
- academics
- social needs/friends
- feeling smothered
- costs (for private school or activities)
I have no experience with homeschooling. The coops-- would any of them see a benefit to a couple of their kids teaching Alice? You or they could pick a subject and maybe for an hour or two a couple times a week they could teach her. The kids would also be learning-- they could be responsible for drafting the lesson plans (with supervision and guidiance) and teaching Alice. That could be a good learning expereince for them as well and it would also provide a bit of the social outlet.
ReplyDeleteA private tutor to work with Alice to offset some of what you teach her and give you both a break from each other (said with a hug). Perhaps talk with a local University education department. They may have un upperlevel student or graduate student who is interested.
Social outlets-- do you have a local FCC organization? YMCA activities or town recreation department sports?
Good suggestions, Reena. The coops tend to structured much like a mini-school, with adults hired to tutor (teach) a class.
DeleteI do have a private tutor working with her on her English reading, conversation and pronunciation twice a week.
Social outlets we have found tend to be either church-related or PE/sports related. They are good, but it is taking time to make friends that she spend time with between events.
We too had to weigh the same decisions. Our daughter came home from Shanghai when she was 12 and at that time didn't know a word of English. This was right at the beginning of Summer and we didn't just want her roaming around our house while we were working, so we placed her in a Summer school program to introduce her to U.S. schools. We also had her assesed by a Chinese speaker and realized her education back in China was pretty lackluster. We went ahead and had her enter 6th grade in the public school system. (She could've started in 7th grade, but we wanted her to have an extra year of English before high school). She had 2 hours of ESL everyday and one of the ESL teachers would sit with her during her other classes. She also joined band, which is a great non-verbal outlet for her. Lin is now in 7th grade and doing great. She has consistently been on the honor roll and enjoys school activities/field trips. She is down to one hour of dedicated ESL a day and asked to join the regular English class. Homework can be a bit of a chore sometimes as we need to help her translate the lessons. It has been good for her to have a social outlet and the kids have all been generally nice to her. She has come a long way and we feel placing her in public school has had many benefits.
ReplyDeleteYour situation sounds like a good fit for us. Unfortunately, I am only being offered 2 hours of ESL instruction PER WEEK and no additional ESL support during her other classes. There is no actual ESL class. The ESL teacher would either work with her in her regular class or pull her out to work with her, at his discretion.
DeleteWhat do you do when the school won't provide the support you know is needed? If we could get the support you have, I positive she would be in school right now.
Have you checked out the Department of Ed website for your state? They may have some resources listed on there or some contacts of people you can call to discuss your situation. It could be that the schools do need to provide Alice with more accomodations but are not doing it because of costs (sad but I've heard of it happening). If a parent isn't aware of how the system works then they school gets away with not providing the accomodation (and saves that money).
DeleteI would think Alice would qualify for an IEP and in that the school and parent all outline the goals for Alice and how those goals will be achieved and how attainment of those goals will be measured.
DeleteI don't think she would qualify for an IEP--I think that's only for special ed kids, but I'm not positive. I think in the language area, they have language plans, but they DO have test her to see if she qualifies for ESL services, then they create a plan on what kinds of services she qualifies for (reduced work, modified assignments, etc...I only know this because I've served our schools LPAC committee--don't ask me what LPAC stands for, but its something having to do with Language learners). HOWEVER, I WOULD call the district's main office and talk to the person in charge of the special programs/ESL program and ask about their services and how it works. If their answer is a bit questionable, then I'd call your state DOE and talk to the ELL department (I've called ours several times regarding our state testing) and ask them about accommodations that your district is required to provide for ELLs. Then go from there. Our state's DOE website is FAR from user friendly, unless of course you know exactly where you need to go! LOL! I'd just call them if you can't find what you need after poking around for a little bit. EM me if you need more direction/what to know what to ask, etc.
DeleteWe had almost the same exact situation with Hope. Ranking our goals for her and comparing them to the strengths of each option helped us find our answer. It was public school. It came down to us realizing that our relationship with her was more important than academics, and homeschooling was not good for our relationship. Her school is not great for academics, but she will catch up eventually because she's so bright, and she thrives off the structure and social interaction.
ReplyDeleteThanks Elissa. When I am honest with myself, I have to admit that I am seeing signs that Alice is determined and strong-willed, not unlike her older sister. As her comfort with us builds and her self confidence comes out, I find myself getting irritated over little things. I attribute it to being a bit strong-willed myself and can see patterns developing that happened with my older daughter. Neither of us liked to be wrong and were slow to concede. Alice fits the pattern to a "T". I am realizing that our relationship has to come first and my comfort level with the school academic situation will just have to take second place. Putting other adults in charge of parts of her day will give me the space I need to be more relaxed and leave me energy to deal with the big stuff.
DeleteI am going to email you!
ReplyDeleteI can understand your dilemma and I feel your pain. I will tell you this, our school (apparently) is very academically challenging. And Rachel was in grade 4 in China, but came here and we put her in her grade level at grade 8. My biggest angst with our district is we are not diverse and therefore have only 1 hour of ESL and the ESL teacher does not work with the teachers really at all, which made me in charge of working with the teachers to tell them what she could and couldn't do. They were wonderful, though, in making adjustments as needed. I can tell you that right now at the end of one school year...Rachel is doing at grade level science with little to no modifications/reduction of work. There are only a few modifications/reduction of work in math as well. Reading/LA they do simplified vocabulary words, which obviously is necessary. Her social studies teacher is also really good about helping her with assignments giving her ones that will be meaningful/helpful yet not going to overwhelm her since US History is all new to her. We hope to move to a new/bigger district (I know we're crazy!) for high school to provide her a better ESL program. I'm afraid they may not academically challenge her as much, but you better bet I will be up there telling them she CAN do much more and requiring them to require her to do more!!!! Because she WILL NOT slack even though sometimes she wants to! :-)
ReplyDeleteWe are in the same boat as Elissa. There is NO WAY that Rachel could home school with me. JUST NO WAY. At the beginning especially, she was constantly asking to go to school...when was she going to start school..etc. We came home in May. Then we hit a rough spot in school and she doesn't really like school--or rather she doesn't like the KIDS at school--and she asked to home school. There's just no way that she & I could do it. There are some nights she gets angry with me trying to help her with homework! There's just no way she could learn everything from me. I explained it to her this way: we need her teachers at school to explain things to her...then if she doesn't understand, she can come home and we can help explain it again to her. So, there are 2-3 different explanations on a concept rather than just me. And she was happy with that explanation. It would never work for our relationship as mom/daughter for me to home school her. She would be angry and challenge me all the time. As it is, she challenges me enough! :-)
But that's just us...we left all options open before we traveled, but it was pretty clear while I was still in China that she needed to go to school. For us, that was the best decision. It helps me stay sane for the several hours of repeated teaching I get to do after school on the concepts she doesn't understand (and believe me--especially at the beginning--it was nightly...for 1-2 hours a night!). So, technically, I STILL home schooled her! Its worth it!